Toronto Home Buying Guide
The short answer
There is no standard percentage below asking that makes an offer reasonable on every Toronto home. An offer 2%, 5% or 10% below asking needs to be judged against recent comparable sales, the property's condition, competing offers and your budget. The asking price alone cannot tell you whether you are getting good value.
A $50,000 reduction can sound like a successful negotiation. But the seller chose the starting price. If that price was too ambitious, the discount may simply bring the home closer to what comparable properties are worth.
Before deciding how far below asking to offer, establish a reasonable value range. Then decide how you want to negotiate within your own financial limits.
1. Start with recent comparable sales
Ask your agent to show you the most relevant recent sales and explain why each one belongs in the comparison. A nearby address and the same number of bedrooms are only the beginning.
Compare the location, lot, usable space, parking, layout, condition and ownership structure. Also consider when each sale happened and whether more recent evidence points to a change in value.
- Detached and semi-detached houses: Pay attention to lot dimensions, parking, renovations, major systems and the usefulness of the finished space.
- Freehold townhouses: Compare similar layouts, interior versus end units, parking arrangements and any shared maintenance obligations.
- Condo townhouses: Consider monthly fees, what those fees cover, the unit's condition and the condominium corporation's financial position.
- Condo apartments: Look for relevant sales in the same building when available, then account for layout, floor, exposure, parking, locker and fees.
If you are considering homes in Highland Creek, West Hill or Guildwood, start with the immediate area and comparable property styles. A sale elsewhere in Scarborough may require substantial adjustments before it becomes a useful reference.
Active listings matter too: they show the alternatives available to you. Their asking prices still need to be tested against actual sale evidence.
2. What current Toronto data tells us
TRREB's October 2026 Market Watch, the latest monthly report available at the time of writing, reported the following sale-to-list-price ratios for the City of Toronto.
Source: TRREB Market Watch, October 2026 . Selected segments are shown to illustrate differences within Toronto.
TRREB calculates this measure by dividing average selling price by average listing price for reported firm sales. These are sale outcomes, not buyers' opening offers, and unsold properties are excluded.
The citywide 98% figure does not establish a recommended 2% discount. It cannot tell you what an individual seller will accept or whether a particular purchase represents good value.
3. What 5% and 10% below asking can actually mean
The examples below use invented numbers to show how the same negotiation question can produce different answers. The assumed value ranges represent what a detailed comparable-sales analysis might support.
Swipe horizontally to view the full comparison.
| Scenario | Asking price | Assumed value range | Illustrative price |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: A supported discount | $1,000,000 | $940,000–$960,000 | $950,000 5% below asking |
| B: A larger discount | $1,000,000 | $850,000–$880,000 | $900,000 10% below asking |
| C: A low asking price | $900,000 | $940,000–$960,000 | $950,000 Approximately 5.6% above asking |
In Scenario A, the price falls within the assumed value range. In Scenario B, even a 10% reduction leaves the price above that range. In Scenario C, a price above asking still fits the assumed value.
This is why the size of the discount deserves less weight than the evidence supporting the purchase price.
These examples compare price with assumed value. They are not recommended opening bids, appraisals or predictions of what a seller will accept.
4. Check the listing's actual negotiating position
Look beyond the latest listing date
Ask about earlier listings, price changes and relistings. A property that appears new today may have been marketed previously. Equally, a recent price reduction may already have brought an ambitious asking price into a reasonable range.
Time on the market is a reason to investigate. It does not reveal the seller's finances, urgency or minimum acceptable price.
Compare the alternatives available today
How many similar homes could you buy instead? Compare their condition, asking prices and suitability. Having several credible alternatives can help you hold your position if this seller wants more than you are prepared to pay.
Understand the competition
Showings and online interest are different from competing written offers. Under RECO's guidance, buyers who submit a written offer are entitled to know the number of competing offers. Other offers' prices and terms are not automatically disclosed; the seller decides whether permitted information is shared.
RECO also explains that competition does not necessarily produce an above-asking sale, and offering the asking price or more does not guarantee acceptance.
5. Decide your opening price and your stopping point
Once you understand the comparable sales and the listing's position, establish three numbers before negotiations begin:
- Your opening offer: A price you can explain using the sales evidence, property differences and current competition.
- Your target purchase price: The outcome you would be comfortable agreeing to if the other terms also work.
- Your maximum purchase price: The most you can afford and are willing to pay, allowing for closing costs, immediate work and ongoing ownership expenses.
A price can fit the comparable-sales evidence and still exceed your personal budget. Both limits matter.
Your agent can support a below-asking offer with a concise explanation of the relevant sales and material differences. If repairs affect your price, use inspection findings or professional estimates where available.
Leave room for negotiation when the circumstances support it, while recognising that a counteroffer is never guaranteed. RECO's guidance for sellers explains that sellers can negotiate, accept an offer or reject all offers.
If a counteroffer arrives, compare it with your evidence and your maximum. Splitting the difference is a negotiating choice; the midpoint does not automatically establish market value.
6. Consider the full offer, including its protections
Ask which closing arrangements would suit the seller and whether you can accommodate them. Clear inclusions, practical deadlines and a deposit you can deliver as agreed can help present a workable proposal. None guarantees a price concession.
Keep the risks of the transaction in view when discussing conditions:
- Financing: The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada states that mortgage preapproval does not guarantee final approval. The lender still considers the property and the financing requirements. Confirm the position with your lender before making financing commitments.
- Property condition: RECO's buyer's checklist recommends considering financing, inspection and other appropriate conditions. Discuss which protections the particular purchase requires.
- Resale condos and condo townhouses: Have your lawyer review the status certificate and supporting documents. The Condominium Authority of Ontario identifies information such as common expenses, reserve funds, assessments and litigation as relevant to this review.
A lower purchase price needs to be assessed alongside the costs and obligations you are taking on. Keep enough room in your budget to own the property comfortably after closing.
Common questions about below-asking offers
Can I offer 10% below asking on a Toronto home?
You can propose that price. Whether it is a sensible opening position depends on the property's supported value and the competition. A substantial gap between asking price and comparable sales gives you a different basis for negotiation than a listing already priced close to those sales. The seller may still reject it.
Should I wait for a price reduction before making an offer?
You can make an offer based on the evidence available now. Waiting may change the seller's position, but it may also allow another buyer to purchase the home. Weigh that possibility against how strongly the property suits you and the alternatives available.
Is a low offer insulting?
Sellers react differently. Focus on presenting a serious, clearly explained proposal with terms you can meet. A respectful explanation can make your reasoning easier to understand, but it cannot make an unacceptable price acceptable to the seller.
Sources and research notes
- TRREB Market Watch, October 2026 — City of Toronto sale-to-list-price ratios and methodology.
- RECO: Competing offers — Asking prices, competition and offer information.
- RECO: Dealing with competing offers — Sellers' options when responding to offers.
- RECO: Buyer's checklist — Budgeting, property review and protective conditions.
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada: Getting preapproved for a mortgage .
- Condominium Authority of Ontario: Status certificates .
Market figures refer to October 2026. The pricing scenarios are fictional illustrations. This article provides general information; review a specific property's pricing, financing and contract terms with your real estate agent, lender and lawyer.
Tom Sachdeva, REALTOR®
RE/MAX Royal Team Sachdeva Realty
647-299-4529